How 9 Cheenta students ranked in top 100 in ISI and CMI Entrances?
Learn More

West Bengal RMO 2015 Problem 2 Solution - Polynomial Problem

The second stage examination of INMO, the Regional Mathematical Olympiad (RMO) is a three hour examination with six problems. The problems under each topic involve high level of difficulty and sophistication. The book, Challenge and Thrill of Pre-College Mathematics is very useful for preparation of RMO. West Bengal RMO 2015 Problem 2 Solution has been written for RMO preparation series.


Let P(x)=x^2+ax+b be a quadratic polynomial where a,b are real numbers. Suppose l\angle P(-1)^2,P(0)^2,P(1)^2r\angle  be an arithmetic progression of positive integers. Prove that a,b are integers.


P(-1) = 1-a+b , P(0) = b, P(1) = 1 + a + b  .
According to the problem

(1-a+b)^2 , b^2 , (1+a+b)^2 are in arithmetic progression of positive integers.

Clearly \dfrac {(1-a+b)^2 + (1+a+b)^2}{2} = b^2

This implies \dfrac {1 + a^2 + b^2 -2a +2b -2ab + 1+ a^2 + b^2 +2a +2b + 2ab}{2} = b^2
\Rightarrow 1 + a^2 + b^2 +2b = b^2
\Rightarrow 1 + a^2 +2b = 0
\Rightarrow 2b = -(1+a^2) implying b is negative.

Now we know (1-a+b)^2  is an integer.

Then 1+a^2 +b^2 -2a +2b -2ab = -2b + b^2 -2a +2b -2ab  (replacing 1+a^2 = -2b  )

This implies b^2 -2a -2ab  is an integer. But b^2 is also an integer. Hence 2a + 2ab  is an integer.

Now we also know (1+a+b)^2  is an integer.

Then 1+a^2 +b^2 +2a +2b +2ab = -2b + b^2 + 2a +2b + 2ab  (replacing 1+a^2 = -2b  )

Again replacing -(1+a^2) = 2b  we get b^2 + 2a - a(1+a^2)  is an integer or (a - a^3)  is an integer.

Note that b^2  is some positive integer. Let it be b^2 = c  . Then b= - sqrt c  where c is some positive integer (as we know b is negative)

1+a^2 = 2\sqrt c  or a^2 = 2 \sqrt c - 1
a(1-a^2) = k  (suppose). Then a(1- (2 \sqrt c - 1)) = k  or 2a(1-\sqrt c) = k
squaring both sides we get
4a^2 (1+c - 2\sqrt c) = k^2
\Rightarrow 4(2 \sqrt c - 1) (1+ c - 2 \sqrt c) = k^2
\Rightarrow 4(2 \sqrt c + 2 c \sqrt c - 4c - 1 - c + 2 \sqrt c) = k^2
\Rightarrow 4(4 \sqrt c + 2c \sqrt c - 5c - 1) = k^2
\Rightarrow (4+2c)\sqrt c = \dfrac{k^2}{4} + 5c + 1
\Rightarrow \sqrt c = \dfrac{k^2 + 20c + 4}{4(4+2c)}

Right hand side is rational. Hence left hand side is also rational. This implies \sqrt c  is rational. Since c is an integer, this implies \sqrt c  is integer. Hence b is integer.

We know a^2 = -2b - 1  . Since b is integer, therefore a^2  is integer.
Again a(1-a^2)  is integer and a^2  is integer, implies a must be rational.

Finally, if a is rational and a^2 is integer then a must be integer.


Knowledge Partner

Cheenta is a knowledge partner of Aditya Birla Education Academy

Cheenta Academy

Aditya Birla Education Academy

Aditya Birla Education Academy

Cheenta. Passion for Mathematics

Advanced Mathematical Science. Taught by olympians, researchers and true masters of the subject.