Categories
Combinatorics IIT JAM Statistics ISI M.Stat PSB ISI MSTAT

ISI MStat PSB 2010 Problem 2 | Combinatorics

This is a beautiful sample problem from ISI MStat 2010 PSB Problem 2. This is based how one can find the number of isosceles triangles with sides of integer length one can construct, using simple counting principles . We provide detailed solution with prerequisites mentioned explicitly.

This is a beautiful sample problem from ISI MStat PSB 2010 Problem 2. It’s all about how many isosceles triangle with sides of integers lengths one can construct under certain conditions. We provide a detailed solution with prerequisites mentioned explicitly.

Problem– ISI MStat PSB 2010 Problem 2

Find the total number of isosceles triangles such that the length of each side is a positive integer less than or equal to 40.

(Here equilateral triangles are also counted as isosceles triangle.)

Prerequisites

  • Basic counting principles.
  • Triangle inequality.

Solution

Let the sides of the isosceles triangle are k, k and l units, (length of the equal sides are k units)

So, our problem is all about finding triplets of form (k,k,l), where \(l, k \le 40\) . And how many such triplets can be found !

also since l,k and k are also sides of an (isosceles) triangle, so by triangle inequality,

\(l < 2k\) . Since l is an integer so, \(l \le 2k-1\)

So, we have \(l\le 40\) and \(l \le 2k-1\). combining we have \(l \le min(40, 2k-1)\) .

now let us define, \( l_k \) : possible number of l’s for a given k =1,2,….,40

here we must consider two cases.

Case-1 : when \(2k-1 \le 40 \Rightarrow k \le \lceil \frac{40+1}{2} \rceil = 20 \)

So, l can be any integer between 1 and 2k-1, since \( l\ \le 2k-1\) when \( k \le 20\)

so,there can be 2k-1 choices for the value of each k, when k=1,…,20.

Or, \( l_k = 2k-1 \) for k=1,2,….,20.

now, Case-2 : when 2k-1>40 \( \Rightarrow k > \lceil \frac{40+1}{2} \rceil = 20 \)

so, here l can take any integer between 1 to 40. So, there 40 choices for l for a given k, when k=21,22,…,40.

Or, \( l_k = 40 \) for k=21,22,….,40.

Combining Case-1 and Case-2, we have,

\(l_k = \begin{cases} 2k-1 & k=1,2,…,20 \\ 40 & k=21,22,…,40 \end{cases}\)

So, finally, let all possible number of triplets of form (k,k,l) are = \(T_40\)

So, \( T_{40} \) = \( \sum_{k=1}^{40}{l_k} \) = \( \sum_{k=1}^{20}{(2k-1)}\) + \( \sum_{k=21}^{40}{40} \) =\( (20 )^2 + 40 \times (40-20)=400+800= 1200. \)

So, \(T_{40}\) = 1200. hence we can find 1200 such isosceles triangles with sides of integer lengths such that the length of each sides are less than or equal to 40.

Food For Thought

Can you generalize this problem? i.e. can you find How many isosceles triangle one can construct, with sides of integer lengths, such that the sides are less than or equal to any integer N ? Can you find an elegant formula to express \(T_N \), for any integer N?

Previous ISI MStat Posts:

2 replies on “ISI MStat PSB 2010 Problem 2 | Combinatorics”

For general $N \in \Bbb N$ we have $$T_N = \left ( \left \lfloor \frac {N+1} {2} \right \rfloor \right )^2 + N^2 – N \left \lfloor \frac {N+1} {2} \right \rfloor.$$

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.